90 Practical Reasons a Nanny is Better Than Daycare

January 18, 2017

When it comes to your child, many parents are unsure which direction to go when it comes to childcare. Should you put your child in a daycare center or consider hiring a nanny?

Many parents believe that a nanny is too expensive. These days, modern nannies are not only affordable and accessible, they also provide a number of benefits that daycare centers cannot match. Not to mention that if you have more than one child in daycare a nanny is almost always cheaper.

In this article child care expert, Martha Scully, will provide you with the information you need to help answer the questions “Why should I hire a nanny?” and “What are the benefits of a nanny over daycare?”

90 Benefits of Hiring a Nanny

Let’s take a look at some of the advantages of a nanny vs daycare.

  1. Your children can sleep in.
  2. Your children have time to enjoy their breakfast.
  3. Your children won’t be exposed to germs from other children.
  4. You can leave for work when YOU are ready.
  5. You don’t have to worry about your children’s allergies.
  6. You don’t have to drive your children in bad weather.
  7. You get to work faster because you don’t have to drive the children to daycare.
  8. You can guide the nanny to create an effective schedule.
  9. More than one child? A nanny is cheaper.
  10. A nanny can get dinner started and help with other household responsibilities.
  11. The security benefit that someone is likely to be home more often.
  12. If your child is sick you do not have to take the day off.
  13. An adult to tend to your pets during the day.
  14. Someone is home for repair people or contractors who need to work in your home.

  15. You and your nanny determine social interactions with other children.

  16. Your child does developmental activities based on their own interests.

  17. Having a second adult reinforce rules of the home.

  18. No snow days.

  19. No morning fights or frustration to get out the door with your child.

  20. No calls from daycare to pick up your child when they are not well.

  21. A nanny can help the children with homework.

  22. Your child receives the individual attention they deserve.

  23. No fights with other kids. 

  24. You regulate the food that your child eats. 

  25. Children with special needs receive more individual attention.

  26. You don’t have to pick your children up after school.

  27. A nanny can do tasks around the home when the children are napping.

  28. A nanny can help with lessons and appointments for your child.

  29. Taking time off work for a sick child and having to pay daycare fee is expensive.

  30. Daycare centres often don’t have part-time care available. You can hire a nanny part time.

  31. A nanny may be willing to care for your children in the evening when you have work functions or a night out with your spouse.

  32. Another adult that loves them.

  33. If you hire a nanny who speaks another language your child learn it too. 

  34. The piece of mind of regular updates from your nanny about what your children are up to while you’re at work.

  35. Your child is more likely to be potty trained faster.

  36. With a nanny, your child can explore different fun activities your area has to offer.
  37. A nanny can go to the grocery store or shop for you.

  38. A nanny can be with your children for many years. Providing your child with more consistency than a daycare.

  39. Your child is being disciplined the way you want.

  40. Your child can learn life skills from your nanny (cooking, sewing, etc)
  41. An adult to ensure your child is properly protected from the sun.

  42. Under the nanny’s supervision, the child has more freedom. 
(daycare does not allow playing in puddles)
  43. If your nanny is from a different country they can teach your child about a new culture.

  44. We all need a mental health day. A nanny can provide this break for your child.
  45. A nanny develops a more intimate bond with your child. 
(hugs when they are hurt, upset or sad)
  46. Your nanny can pick up cues on when your child is unhappy and acts fast to ensure their mood does not get out of hand.

  47. You’re more likely to have a closer bond with a nanny than the staff at the daycare.

  48. Have a late night meeting? With a daycare you are limited by a closing time. 

  49. Your children can play with their own toys.

  50. Your children can nap in their own beds.

  51. A pair of extra hands at your child’s birthday party.

  52. No parents judging you or your child.

  53. Your child is not being hit and or being bit by other children.
(common in daycare toddler rooms)
  54. A nanny may be willing to work on holidays. 

  55. Your child can make a snowman and do snow play activity as long as they like.

  56. If you do not feel the nanny is not a good fit you can hire a different one. Not able to do this with daycare staff.

  57. If you have a live-in nanny you have a ton of flexibility.

  58. If you want to get away for a night or two with your spouse you can ask your nanny to help.

  59. Your nanny can help your child build that lego set they got for Christmas.
  60. If you want to work from a different location like a cottage or hotel your nanny may be able to come with you.
  61. Your nanny and child can meet you at your workplace for a visit.

  62. If you are breastfeeding a nanny can provide your child with breast milk that you have pumped.

  63. Cloth diapers are possible with a nanny. Not really welcome with a daycare centers.

  64. Less rules, your child can climb trees, and get dirty. 

  65. Your nanny can take your pet to the vet.

  66. A nanny may be willing to house sit while you are on vacation.

  67. A nanny can help plan & prepare for parties.

  68. Your nanny can ensure your child is well hydrated. Daycare teachers are often too busy.

  69. A nanny can help with other household tasks.

  70. Daycare centres tend to have high turnover.

  71. Daycare centres can be loud, over-stimulating places.

  72. Your nanny can develop relationships with other nannies and therefore they can organize fun play dates in the safety and comfort of your home.

  73. If your nanny agrees to a nanny cam you can watch what your child does during the day.
  74. If your child has an emergency your nanny can act quicker and will be well aware of your child’s allergies and other medical conditions. She also will be aware on how to immediately reach you.

  75. A nanny can reinforce and teach your child rules of the home. A second person reinforcing the family routine.

  76. A nanny is more likely better for children with special needs.

  77. Many daycare centers must only meet minimum safety and sanitary regulations.

  78. Your child is less likely to get exposure to sickness from other children.

  79. Your child will be able to attend wonderful neighbourhood programs at the library.

  80. Siblings get to spend the days together rather than apart at a daycare center.

  81. You don’t get involved in the politics of a daycare center. 

  82. You get to incentivize your nanny for all her hard work through raises and bonuses. 

  83. With a nanny, much less planning and preparing the night before.
  84. Much easier to find a nanny then get into a daycare centre. Especially with an infant.

  85. Better quality food at home than a daycare.

  86. For spouses less stress and arguing over chores because a nanny can take some household duties off your plate.
  87. Your children learn more about cooking and cleaning than they would at a daycare
  88. More quality time with your children because your nanny can take care of so many household responsibilities off your plate.
  89. Your child is not learning negative behaviours and habits from other children.

  90. You can develop your own lesson plans and activities that you want your child to do at home with the nanny.


Providing your child with a secure loving environment is what every parent wants. Research has proven that a child in the first five years of development needs care when they are sick, hurt, or sad. A nanny can provide this individual attention better than a daycare centre.

Let Us Guide You Through The Process of Finding a Nanny or Nanny Job

CanadianNanny.ca is Canada’s largest and most trusted online service for finding nannies and babysitters. We have been recognized by Today’s Parent, CanadaAM, the Globe & Mail, Reader’s Digest, Canadian Living Magazine, and many reputable parenting websites and publications across Canada.

Contact Us

Although we may be a self-serve nanny service, we are still very much devoted to helping families and caregivers succeed in their search for a match through our site. Our customer support team is always here and happy to offer any advice to our potential and existing customers.

Nanny Hiring Ressources

Need a Nanny?

Need a Nanny Job?

Canadian Nanny Payroll and Tax Service powered by Heartpayroll